Consultation response: public finances in 2023-24

Response from the David Hume Institute to the Scottish Parliament call for views on Scotland’s public finances in 2023-24 and the impact of the cost of living and public service reform.

About our submission

DHI welcomes the opportunity to respond to the Finance and Public Administration Committee’s call for views on Scotland’s public finances 2023-24 and the impact of the cost of living and public service reform.

Central to our work are the people of Scotland, including those who are seldom heard; from different ethnic and cultural backgrounds; different genders, ages and abilities. 

We apply the critical thinking which has long defined DHI to encourage action to address the contemporary issues of our time. 

Our response draws on a range of previous research including:

• The Action Project - the largest multi generational research project in Scotland in recent years heard from over 5,000 people about their thoughts on action to help Scotland build forward better.

• Our 2022 briefing paper on open data, which sets out the lack of progress on open data in Scotland and the cost to the economy and public services.

Summary

We call on the Committee to recommend that the Scottish Government:

• Maintain the essential focus on commitments to reducing child poverty and the transition to net zero is critical to the economy

• Fully implement the Scottish Government’s 2021 benefit take-up strategy

• Recognise that there is little evidence that tax cuts will help with the cost of living or inflation

• Work to reduce levels of ‘inactivity’ amongst those who want to work by reducing barriers to work in order to increase the tax base.

• Fully realise the benefits of their own Open Data commitments to improve public services and boost the economy.

• Better utilise the sustainable procurement duty to deliver national outcomes

Scottish Government consultation response: tax policy and the budget

In autumn 2021 the Scottish Government sought views on the overarching approach to tax policy, through Scotland’s first framework for tax.

Our consultation draws on:

• The largest multi generational research project in Scotland in the last five years, The Action Project. In 2020-21 we brought together people from across Scotland to consider the actions needed to move faster towards a more prosperous, sustainable, inclusive and fair country.  Over 5,000 people from across Scotland told us their actions to help Scotland build forward better.

• We worked with partners to reach people of all ages and backgrounds across Scotland.  These included U3A, the Scottish Youth Parliament, the Children’s Parliament and local organisations like InspirAlba in Campbeltown and Resonate Together in Alloa. By listening to the many voices and then analysing themes and patterns, WhatsYourAction.scot presents the findings and encourages others to have their say.

• Our 2021 briefing paper on multi-year budgeting, explains how a new agreement on multi-year budgeting between the Scottish Government and Scottish Parliament will help long-term thinking and support a more open conversation about spending plans and investment choices.

• David Hume Institute events and discussions such as Talking Tax with Charlotte Barbour and Dr Arun Advani last year.

Summary

• DHI welcomes the framework.  The clear, accessible language is critical to create more understanding about the important role tax plays in society. Research conversations as part of the Action Project emphasised the lack of understanding of Scotland’s tax powers.

• Having a coherent narrative that joins up tax policy with the National Performance Framework and Climate Change Plan helps businesses and investors plan for the medium term direction of travel.

• Simplification and public understanding are rightly identified as important factors to underpin a fair tax system and are critical to accountability. The framework’s movement away from language like “tax burden” is important for a fresh conversation.

• DHI welcomes the proposed Citizen Assembly on council tax - this is an area that is widely recognised as needing reform but has become highly political. It came up consistently in Professor Duncan Maclennan’s work A Scotland of Better Places. Continuing the status quo indefinitely should not be an option and this work should be expedited.